Beyond the Complaint Count: Car Rental Experiences at John F. Kennedy International Airport

Jan Nowak

Traveler with suitcase speaking with a car rental representative at an airport counter

We studied car rental experiences at John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York City to identify the factors shaping customer perception. We examined recurring praise and complaints about obtaining a vehicle, interacting with staff, resolving problems and returning the car. A single sentiment label summarizes an account, but it can obscure differences between the experiences described within it.

We collected publicly available online reviews that we could locate in October 2026. We selected companies for which we found at least 2,000 reviews about service at the airport: Avis Car Rental, Budget Car Rental, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Hertz Car Rental and SIXT Car Rental. That threshold determined company eligibility, not the number of reviews we analyzed for each company. We did not establish the reviews’ publication dates.

We analyzed both complete reviews and individual customer statements. Whole-review sentiment describes the overall assessment of an account and uses reviews as its denominator. Claim-level sentiment describes individual statements and uses those statements as its denominator. One review can contribute several statements, including both praise and criticism, so a negative overall assessment need not make every part of the rental negative.

We follow pickup speed and staff interactions, then examine problem resolution, vehicle condition and returns. Keeping overall assessments separate from specific experiences helps us understand the different dimensions of customers’ accounts without treating them as one uniform judgment.

Overall review sentiment across the researched datasets

Overall review sentiment across the researched datasets

Positive, neutral and negative shares of analyzed whole reviews.

Positive
Neutral
Negative
Avis Car Rental
72.0
1.5
26.5
Budget Car Rental
17.1
3.0
79.9
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
73.5
1.0
25.5
Hertz Car Rental
32.7
1.5
65.8
SIXT Car Rental
74.0
1.5
24.5
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
Each bar is 100% of classified review documents for that dataset. Counts and denominators are embedded in the HTML.

Whole-review sentiment classifies each complete review. It differs from the tone of individual statements and the frequency of particular complaints.

Within these datasets, SIXT Car Rental had the highest positive share and lowest negative share. Budget Car Rental had the lowest positive share and highest negative share. Neutral shares ranged from 1.0% for Enterprise Rent-A-Car to 3.0% for Budget Car Rental. These comparisons concern the same measure—sentiment among each company’s analyzed reviews—not overall provider quality.

The overall balance leaves open which rental stages shaped those assessments. We examine individual statements and specific themes to distinguish the reported experiences beneath these broad labels.

Sentiment within individual customer claims

Sentiment within individual customer claims

Positive, neutral and negative shares of individually classified claims.

Positive
Neutral
Negative
Avis Car Rental
53.7
14.3
32.1
Budget Car Rental
15.9
22.8
61.4
Enterprise Rent-A-Car
54.2
19.5
26.3
Hertz Car Rental
22.3
27.0
50.7
SIXT Car Rental
53.7
17.4
28.9
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
Each bar is 100% of classified claims for that dataset. Counts and denominators are embedded in the HTML.

One review can contain several statements, including both praise and criticism, so claim shares need not match whole-review shares. These percentages describe classified statements, not independent customers.

Positive statements formed a majority for Avis Car Rental, Enterprise Rent-A-Car and SIXT Car Rental. Negative statements formed a majority for Budget Car Rental and Hertz Car Rental.

Enterprise Rent-A-Car had the highest positive claim share, at 54.2%, and lowest negative share, at 26.3%. Budget Car Rental had the lowest positive share, at 15.9%, and highest negative share, at 61.4%. Neutral shares ranged from 14.3% for Avis Car Rental to 27.0% for Hertz Car Rental.

We use this statement-level view to complement the overall assessments. The sentiment totals alone do not identify the rental stages discussed or establish which particular reviews combined praise and criticism.

Complaint topics across the researched datasets

Complaint topics across the researched datasets

Share of each cohort's negative reviews carrying the same complaint topic.

Complaint topicAvis Car RentalBudget Car RentalEnterprise Rent-A-CarHertz Car RentalSIXT Car Rental
Claims Problem Resolution17.011.927.512.230.6
Customer Support7.511.317.613.08.2
Overall Satisfaction Recommendation1.90.00.00.82.0
Pricing Value9.48.85.911.516.3
Product Service Quality15.115.123.515.318.4
Sales Onboarding Experience1.93.12.03.18.2
Speed Efficiency37.745.35.935.96.1
Technical Issues Bugs3.81.35.92.36.1
Trust Transparency5.72.511.85.34.1
Usability User Experience0.00.60.00.80.0
Values show the share of each dataset’s negative reviews carrying the complaint topic. Topics may overlap; hover cells for counts and denominators.

Complaint-topic percentages use negative reviews in each company’s dataset as their denominator, rather than all reviews or all rentals. A negative review can cover several topics, so these shares do not describe mutually exclusive customer groups.

Speed and efficiency showed a substantial cross-company difference. Among negative reviews in each dataset, this topic had its highest share at Budget Car Rental, at 45.3%, followed by Avis Car Rental at 37.7% and Hertz Car Rental at 35.9%. The corresponding shares were 6.1% for SIXT Car Rental and 5.9% for Enterprise Rent-A-Car, the lowest in these datasets.

Claims handling and problem resolution occupied larger shares than speed and efficiency within the negative-review groups for SIXT Car Rental and Enterprise Rent-A-Car: 30.6% and 27.5%, respectively. The comparable problem-resolution shares were 17.0% for Avis Car Rental, 12.2% for Hertz Car Rental and 11.9% for Budget Car Rental. SIXT Car Rental had the highest share and Budget Car Rental the lowest for this topic.

Product and service quality appeared in 23.5% of negative Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews. The corresponding shares for Avis Car Rental and Budget Car Rental were 15.1% each. Pricing and value appeared in 16.3% of negative SIXT Car Rental reviews and 5.9% of negative Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews.

We use the topic mix to locate concerns within negative feedback. It distinguishes an emphasis on speed from an emphasis on resolving problems; it does not measure an individual renter’s risk or establish why the company profiles differ.

Top positive patterns by company

Top positive patterns by company

Each row lists one dataset's three leading positive patterns by mapped claim count.

BrandPattern 1Pattern 2Pattern 3
Avis Car RentalDaniel is described favorably.
24 mapped claims
The reviewer describes Victor Castillo favorably.
23 mapped claims
The reviewer expresses strong positive evaluations of Tiffany.
19 mapped claims
Budget Car RentalReviewers report very positive experiences at the location.
17 mapped claims
The car ran satisfactorily.
13 mapped claims
The location or facility was clean.
11 mapped claims
Enterprise Rent-A-CarCustomers describe the car as clean.
23 mapped claims
Customers describe the staff as friendly.
23 mapped claims
Customers regard the service as excellent.
21 mapped claims
Hertz Car RentalThe return was easy.
15 mapped claims
Reviewers prefer Hertz over other rental car companies and treat it as their go-to rental company.
13 mapped claims
The car was excellent
12 mapped claims
SIXT Car RentalThe service was rated positively.
28 mapped claims
The reviewer experienced a highly positive rental experience at SIXT.
19 mapped claims
The reviewer describes the rental experience as very good.
18 mapped claims
Each row is one analyzed dataset. Pattern 1, 2 and 3 are ranked by mapped claim count within that dataset; ties use document count, then label. A dash means fewer than three patterns were available. Document counts and percentages remain in data attributes.

We rank each company’s three leading positive patterns by the number of classified statements about each pattern. The percentages below measure a different unit: the share of all analyzed reviews for that company mentioning the pattern, including reviews that were not positive overall.

For Avis Car Rental, praise for three named people occupied the first three places. Each pattern appeared in 3.5% of analyzed Avis Car Rental reviews. Their different statement rankings therefore did not reflect different review shares.

Budget Car Rental’s leading pattern covered broadly positive experiences at the location, appearing in 6.0% of its analyzed reviews. Satisfactory vehicle operation ranked second and clean facilities third, each at 5.0%.

Clean cars and friendly staff tied for the leading statement total at Enterprise Rent-A-Car. Each appeared in 10.5% of its analyzed reviews, followed by excellent service at 10.0%.

Hertz Car Rental’s leading pattern was easy returns, appearing in 7.0% of its analyzed reviews. Expressed preference for the company ranked second and excellent cars third, each at 5.5%.

Positive service assessments led for SIXT Car Rental, appearing in 13.0% of its analyzed reviews. Two separately classified broad rental-experience patterns followed, each at 8.0%.

Praise covered people and vehicles as well as facilities and returns. These patterns differ in specificity, so we do not treat their rankings as a common service-quality scale. A theme outside a company’s top three may still appear in its feedback.

Top negative patterns by company

Top negative patterns by company

Each row lists one dataset's three leading negative patterns by mapped claim count.

BrandPattern 1Pattern 2Pattern 3
Avis Car RentalThe reviewer experienced prolonged waiting to obtain access to the car.
21 mapped claims
The reviewer evaluates the customer service negatively.
19 mapped claims
Customers experience a long wait.
17 mapped claims
Budget Car RentalCustomers experience rude staff behavior.
25 mapped claims
The reviewer experiences additional waiting before receiving the vehicle.
23 mapped claims
Customers encounter a long line.
23 mapped claims
Enterprise Rent-A-CarReviewers describe the experience as terrible or negative.
19 mapped claims
The reviewer gives the experience an extremely low rating.
18 mapped claims
The reviewer reports receiving no effective customer service.
14 mapped claims
Hertz Car RentalReviewers wait a prolonged time for a car.
24 mapped claims
The reviewer is upset.
16 mapped claims
Reviewers state they will not rent from the location again.
15 mapped claims
SIXT Car RentalThe reviewer characterizes the experience with the provider as bad.
19 mapped claims
The reviewer expresses dissatisfaction with the service.
17 mapped claims
Reviewers describe the dealership customer service as poor or disappointing.
17 mapped claims
Each row is one analyzed dataset. Pattern 1, 2 and 3 are ranked by mapped claim count within that dataset; ties use document count, then label. A dash means fewer than three patterns were available. Document counts and percentages remain in data attributes.

We also rank each company’s three leading negative patterns by classified statement totals. Their percentages describe shares of all analyzed reviews for that company, including reviews that were not negative overall.

For Avis Car Rental, prolonged waiting to access the car led, appearing in 8.5% of its analyzed reviews. Negative customer-service evaluations followed at 7.0%, then general long waits at 7.5%. Customer-service criticism ranked above general long waits by statement total despite appearing in a smaller share of reviews.

For Budget Car Rental, rude staff behavior ranked first, appearing in 12.1% of its analyzed reviews. Additional waiting before receiving the vehicle and long lines followed, tied by statement total, with review shares of 11.6% and 10.6%, respectively.

Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s leading patterns were broadly negative experiences, extremely low ratings and ineffective customer service. They appeared in 7.0%, 6.5% and 5.0% of its analyzed reviews, respectively.

For Hertz Car Rental, prolonged waiting for a car led at 12.1% of its analyzed reviews. Expressions of being upset ranked second at 6.5%, followed by stated intentions not to rent from the location again at 7.5%.

For SIXT Car Rental, bad experiences led at 7.5% of its analyzed reviews. Service dissatisfaction and poor customer service tied next by statement total, with review shares of 6.0% and 5.5%.

These selections distinguish concrete pickup and staff complaints from broader expressions of dissatisfaction. Their differing definitions matter: a general negative verdict does not identify a service stage as precisely as waiting for a vehicle does. A theme missing from the selected patterns is not necessarily absent from the feedback.

What the combined findings reveal

We find distinct assessments of pickup delays, staff interactions, vehicle condition and returns across these datasets. Those dimensions add detail that an overall sentiment label does not provide.

Among each company’s analyzed reviews, negative whole-review shares ranged from 24.5% for SIXT Car Rental, through 25.5% for Enterprise Rent-A-Car and 26.5% for Avis Car Rental, to 65.8% for Hertz Car Rental and 79.9% for Budget Car Rental.

Negative sentiment accounted for 61.4% of classified claims in the Budget Car Rental dataset and 50.7% in the Hertz Car Rental dataset, below their respective negative whole-review shares. These measures classify different units: complete accounts and individual statements. Their numerical differences do not establish which reviews combined praise and criticism.

The topic analysis locates more specific concerns. Speed and efficiency featured in 45.3% of negative Budget Car Rental reviews, 37.7% of negative Avis Car Rental reviews and 35.9% of negative Hertz Car Rental reviews. For Enterprise Rent-A-Car and SIXT Car Rental, problem resolution occupied larger shares of negative feedback than speed and efficiency did.

Positive patterns identify other dimensions: named-person praise for Avis Car Rental, satisfactory vehicle operation for Budget Car Rental, clean cars and friendly staff for Enterprise Rent-A-Car, easy returns for Hertz Car Rental and favorable service assessments for SIXT Car Rental.

We use sentiment, topics and patterns as complementary descriptions of reported experiences, not interchangeable service-quality scores. The findings describe the analyzed feedback rather than all airport renters. Review publication dates remain unknown.

Avis Car Rental: positive and negative experiences

The leading positive patterns in the Avis Car Rental dataset recognized named people. Its leading negative patterns concerned waiting and customer service.

Overall, 72.0% of analyzed Avis Car Rental reviews were positive, 1.5% neutral and 26.5% negative.

The three leading positive patterns, ranked by classified statement total, praised Daniel first, Victor second and Tiffany third. Each appeared in 3.5% of all analyzed Avis Car Rental reviews. Their equal review shares accompanied different statement totals. The summaries establish personal recognition without detailing what each person did.

In the broader topic analysis, customer support featured positively in 59.7% of positive Avis Car Rental reviews. That percentage uses only positive reviews as its denominator, unlike the all-review pattern shares.

What Drives Negative Feedback for Avis Car Rental?

Visual weight follows the mapped claims for the leading negative patterns.

The reviewer experienced prolonged waiting to obtain access to the car.
21 mapped claims
The reviewer evaluates the customer service negatively.
19 mapped claims
Customers experience a long wait.
17 mapped claims
Categories reflect recurring negative themes in the analyzed dataset.

Prolonged waiting to obtain the car led the negative patterns and appeared in 8.5% of all analyzed Avis Car Rental reviews. Negative customer-service evaluations ranked second by statement total, appearing in 7.0%. A more general long-wait pattern ranked third, appearing in 7.5% of all analyzed Avis Car Rental reviews.

Among negative Avis Car Rental reviews, speed and efficiency concerns appeared in 37.7%, compared with 17.0% for claims handling and problem resolution.

Named-person praise and criticism of obtaining the vehicle address different aspects of perception. The aggregate summaries do not establish whether those assessments came from the same reviewers or how long the reported waits lasted.

Budget Car Rental: positive and negative experiences

In the Budget Car Rental dataset, 79.9% of analyzed reviews were negative, 17.1% positive and 3.0% neutral. The specific patterns distinguish praise for vehicles and facilities from criticism of staff behavior and obtaining a car.

General reports of a very positive experience ranked first among positive patterns by classified statement total and appeared in 6.0% of all analyzed Budget Car Rental reviews. Satisfactory vehicle operation ranked second and clean premises third; each appeared in 5.0% of all analyzed Budget Car Rental reviews. Those equal review shares did not mean equal statement totals.

Praise for a car that ran satisfactorily or for clean premises concerns a specific part of the experience. It does not establish approval of every rental stage.

What Drives Negative Feedback for Budget Car Rental?

Visual weight follows the mapped claims for the leading negative patterns.

Customers experience rude staff behavior.
25 mapped claims
The reviewer experiences additional waiting before receiving the vehicle.
23 mapped claims
Customers encounter a long line.
23 mapped claims
Categories reflect recurring negative themes in the analyzed dataset.

Rude staff behavior led the negative patterns by statement total, appearing in 12.1% of all analyzed Budget Car Rental reviews. Additional waiting before receiving the vehicle followed at 11.6%, while long lines appeared in 10.6% of all analyzed Budget Car Rental reviews. The latter two patterns tied by statement total despite their different review shares.

Staff conduct concerns an interaction; waiting for a vehicle and standing in a queue describe delays. These categories need not identify separate groups of reviewers.

Speed and efficiency concerns appeared in 45.3% of negative Budget Car Rental reviews. That topic percentage uses negative reviews as its denominator, while the pattern percentages use all analyzed Budget Car Rental reviews.

We therefore distinguish vehicle and facility assessments from pickup and interaction complaints. The aggregates do not establish that the same reviewers praised one dimension and criticized another.

Enterprise Rent-A-Car: positive and negative experiences

Among analyzed Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews, 73.5% were positive, 25.5% negative and 1.0% neutral. The leading patterns distinguish praise for vehicles and staff from criticism of ineffective assistance.

Clean cars and friendly staff tied as the leading positive patterns by classified statement total. Each appeared in 10.5% of all analyzed Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews. General descriptions of excellent service followed, appearing in 10.0% of all analyzed reviews for the company.

These patterns cover a concrete assessment of the car, impressions of staff and a broader service verdict. In the separate topic analysis, customer support appeared in 41.5% of positive Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews. That denominator differs from the all-review pattern shares.

What Drives Negative Feedback for Enterprise Rent-A-Car?

Visual weight follows the mapped claims for the leading negative patterns.

Reviewers describe the experience as terrible or negative.
19 mapped claims
The reviewer gives the experience an extremely low rating.
18 mapped claims
The reviewer reports receiving no effective customer service.
14 mapped claims
Categories reflect recurring negative themes in the analyzed dataset.

The leading negative pattern described a broadly terrible or negative experience, appearing in 7.0% of all analyzed Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews. Extremely low ratings ranked second, at 6.5%, followed by reports of no effective customer service, at 5.0% of all analyzed reviews for the company.

The first two patterns express dissatisfaction without identifying a particular service stage. The third identifies a complaint about assistance.

Claims handling and problem resolution featured in 27.5% of negative Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews, compared with 23.5% for product or service quality and 17.6% for customer support. These percentages describe the negative-review group, not complaint rates among all renters.

Friendly interactions and clean vehicles address different dimensions from effective assistance. The dataset contains both kinds of assessment, but the aggregates do not establish that they came from the same reviewers.

Hertz Car Rental: positive and negative experiences

Easy returns and difficult vehicle collection both featured among the leading patterns in the Hertz Car Rental dataset. Overall, 65.8% of analyzed Hertz Car Rental reviews were negative, 32.7% positive and 1.5% neutral.

Easy returns led the selected positive patterns by classified statement total and appeared in 7.0% of all analyzed Hertz Car Rental reviews. Expressed preference for Hertz Car Rental as a go-to rental company ranked second, while praise for an excellent car ranked third. Each appeared in 5.5% of all analyzed Hertz Car Rental reviews.

Their equal review shares and different statement rankings reflect the two measures’ different units. These themes express approval of returns, preference for the company and satisfaction with the vehicle; they do not establish that every part of those rentals went smoothly.

What Drives Negative Feedback for Hertz Car Rental?

Visual weight follows the mapped claims for the leading negative patterns.

Reviewers wait a prolonged time for a car.
24 mapped claims
The reviewer is upset.
16 mapped claims
Reviewers state they will not rent from the location again.
15 mapped claims
Categories reflect recurring negative themes in the analyzed dataset.

Prolonged waiting for a car led the selected negative patterns, appearing in 12.1% of all analyzed Hertz Car Rental reviews. General expressions of being upset ranked second by statement total and appeared in 6.5% of all analyzed Hertz Car Rental reviews. Stated intentions not to rent from the location again ranked third at 7.5%.

The broader upset category ranked higher by statement total despite appearing in a smaller share of reviews.

Speed and efficiency featured in 35.9% of negative Hertz Car Rental reviews. That topic percentage uses negative reviews as its denominator, while the pattern shares use all analyzed Hertz Car Rental reviews.

Praise for returning a vehicle and criticism of obtaining one assess separate rental stages. The aggregates do not establish whether the same reviewers reported both, or whether waiting prompted intentions not to return.

SIXT Car Rental: positive and negative experiences

Among analyzed SIXT Car Rental reviews, 74.0% were positive, 1.5% neutral and 24.5% negative. The patterns and topics identify more specific assessments within that overall balance.

A favorable assessment of service led the positive patterns, appearing in 13.0% of all analyzed SIXT Car Rental reviews. Highly positive rental experiences ranked second and descriptions of a very good rental third. Each appeared in 8.0% of all analyzed SIXT Car Rental reviews. Their equal review shares accompanied different classified statement totals, which determined their order.

These patterns capture broad approval without isolating a particular rental stage. The separate topic analysis adds detail: customer support featured in 44.6% of positive SIXT Car Rental reviews, while speed and efficiency featured in 10.8%.

What Drives Negative Feedback for SIXT Car Rental?

Visual weight follows the mapped claims for the leading negative patterns.

The reviewer characterizes the experience with the provider as bad.
19 mapped claims
The reviewer expresses dissatisfaction with the service.
17 mapped claims
Reviewers describe the dealership customer service as poor or disappointing.
17 mapped claims
Categories reflect recurring negative themes in the analyzed dataset.

The leading negative pattern characterized the rental experience as bad, appearing in 7.5% of all analyzed SIXT Car Rental reviews. Dissatisfaction with service followed at 6.0%, alongside poor or disappointing customer service at 5.5% of all analyzed SIXT Car Rental reviews. The latter two patterns tied by statement total despite their different review shares.

Claims handling and problem resolution appeared in 30.6% of negative SIXT Car Rental reviews, compared with 18.4% for product or service quality and 16.3% for pricing and value. These percentages describe negative reviews, not all reviews or the likelihood of a rental problem.

The SIXT Car Rental dataset combines broad approval overall with an emphasis on problem resolution within negative feedback. The aggregates do not establish whether those assessments came from the same reviewers, so they cannot describe the course of an individual rental.

What the findings add up to

Waiting featured prominently in the Avis Car Rental, Budget Car Rental and Hertz Car Rental complaint patterns. Within the negative-review topic mixes for Enterprise Rent-A-Car and SIXT Car Rental, claims handling and problem resolution received more emphasis than speed and efficiency.

Speed and efficiency concerns appeared in 37.7% of negative Avis Car Rental reviews, 45.3% of negative Budget Car Rental reviews and 35.9% of negative Hertz Car Rental reviews. Claims handling and problem resolution appeared in 27.5% of negative Enterprise Rent-A-Car reviews and 30.6% of negative SIXT Car Rental reviews.

Praise covered other dimensions: named people at Avis Car Rental, satisfactory vehicle operation at Budget Car Rental, friendly staff and clean cars at Enterprise Rent-A-Car, easy returns at Hertz Car Rental and favorable service assessments at SIXT Car Rental. These separate aggregates do not establish whether praise and criticism came from the same reviewers.

We use whole-review sentiment, individual statements and specific themes together to understand reported experiences. Their different units and denominators reveal different dimensions of customer perception; they are not interchangeable quality scores. With review publication dates unknown, the findings describe the analyzed feedback and do not predict an individual renter’s experience.

Figures come from the analyzed public-review datasets. Overall review sentiment and sentiment within individual claims use separate denominators.

Share this post
One Comment
  1. Mark B

    hey, thanks for sharing!

Leave a Reply