We studied publicly available online reviews of six car rental companies serving Newark Liberty International Airport: ACE Rent A Car, Avis Car Rental, Budget Car Rental, Drivo Rent A Car, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, and Hertz Car Rental. We asked which experiences shape customer perceptions and whether the themes renters describe recur across companies or vary. A single tidy verdict would be convenient. It would also blur the differences in the feedback.
We collected reviews in November 2026. We included companies for which our research system found at least 3,000 publicly available reviews of service at Newark Liberty International Airport. We did not establish when those reviews were published.
We examined sentiment across whole reviews, sentiment within individual claims, and topics identified in negative reviews. These measures use different units and denominators. A review can express an overall negative view while containing positive claims, so whole-review and claim-level sentiment are not interchangeable. Negative-topic shares describe topics mentioned in negative reviews, not the tone of all reviews.
Our research examines how renters describe staff interactions and concerns such as efficiency, problem resolution, transparency, vehicle condition, and refunds. The patterns describe customer perceptions in the reviewed feedback. They do not explain the causes of those experiences or rank companies.
Overall review sentiment across the researched datasets
Positive reviews made up 75.0% of reviews in the ACE Rent A Car dataset. Neutral reviews accounted for 3.6%, and negative reviews for 21.4%. In the Avis Car Rental dataset, 85.4% of reviews were positive, 2.5% neutral, and 12.1% negative. Budget Car Rental’s reviews were 59.0% positive, 1.0% neutral, and 40.0% negative.
For Drivo Rent A Car, 64.5% of reviews were positive, 1.5% neutral, and 34.0% negative. Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s reviews were 81.7% positive, 2.0% neutral, and 16.2% negative. In the Hertz Car Rental dataset, 24.4% of reviews were positive, 0.5% neutral, and 75.1% negative.
Among these analyzed datasets, Avis Car Rental had the highest positive share and the lowest negative share. Hertz Car Rental had the lowest positive share and the highest negative share. Neutral reviews were a small share in every cohort, ranging from 0.5% for Hertz Car Rental to 3.6% for ACE Rent A Car. These figures describe the overall tone of reviews in the analyzed datasets. They do not explain why experiences differed or rank service quality.
Sentiment within individual customer claims
Claim-level sentiment differs from whole-review sentiment. One review may include both praise and criticism, while claim-level analysis classifies the sentiment of its component claims. The percentages here describe the mix of classified claims in each dataset, not the share of reviews or customers expressing each sentiment.
Positive claims made up the largest share in Avis Car Rental’s dataset, at 61.0%, followed by Enterprise Rent-A-Car at 57.5%. Hertz Car Rental had the smallest positive share, at 15.9%. Hertz had the highest share of negative claims, at 57.5%, while Enterprise had the lowest, at 20.3%.
Budget Car Rental and Drivo Rent A Car each had more negative than positive claims. Negative claims made up 44.0% of Budget’s classified claims and 42.5% of Drivo’s, compared with positive shares of 37.3% and 37.9%, respectively. ACE Rent A Car’s claim mix was less tilted in either direction: 46.5% of its claims were positive and 31.8% negative. Neutral claims ranged from 16.9% of Avis’s claims to 26.6% of Hertz’s.
A review can receive an overall negative tone even when it contains positive claims, so the two measures need not move together. Claim-level sentiment makes the contrast between Hertz and Enterprise especially clear. It does not explain why their reported experiences differ or establish which company provides better service. These are descriptive patterns in the analyzed feedback, not a provider ranking.
Complaint topics across the researched datasets
Negative reviews from the six Newark Liberty International Airport cohorts emphasized different topics. Each percentage gives the share of negative reviews in that company’s dataset that mentioned the named topic.
Problem resolution appeared in 39.0% of ACE Rent A Car’s negative reviews, compared with 23.9% for Drivo Rent A Car and 11.5% for Hertz Car Rental, the lowest share among the six cohorts. Trust and transparency concerns appeared in 34.1% of ACE’s negative reviews and 25.4% of Drivo’s. Among the other four cohorts, the comparable shares ranged from 4.2% for Avis Car Rental to 7.7% for Budget Car Rental. Speed and efficiency was the leading listed topic for Budget. It appeared in 44.9% of Budget’s negative reviews, compared with 23.6% for Hertz and no more than 9.0% in the other datasets.
Customer-support complaints appeared in 33.3% of Avis Car Rental’s negative reviews and 34.4% of Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s. Product and service quality reached its highest share in the Hertz dataset, at 29.7%. These differences describe the issues mentioned in the analyzed negative reviews. They do not explain why experiences differed or establish a service-quality ranking. One negative review can describe more than one issue, so topic percentages do not have to add up to 100%.
Top positive patterns by company
Positive feedback covered broad service assessments, staff interactions, and practical parts of the rental experience, including vehicle condition and ease of return. The themes describe different aspects of customer experience rather than one shared measure of satisfaction.
In the ACE Rent A Car dataset, positive assessments of service appeared in 17.7% of reviews, and favorable comments about the rental car appeared in 14.1%. Praise for Shaun’s customer service appeared in 9.4% of reviews. Avis Car Rental’s leading pattern was positive customer-service feedback, found in 12.1% of reviews. Expressions of gratitude and strongly positive service evaluations each appeared in 11.1%. Budget Car Rental’s leading patterns were highly positive service opinions, in 12.8% of reviews, and satisfaction, in 10.8%. Positive remarks mentioning Antoinette appeared in 4.1% of reviews.
For Drivo Rent A Car, ease of process ranked first by claim count, followed by positive evaluations of the car and positive customer-service assessments. The car-related pattern appeared in 11.2% of reviews, while each of the other two appeared in 10.2%. Pattern rank follows claim counts, while these percentages describe the share of reviews containing each pattern. The two measures can produce a different order.
Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s leading positive theme was pleasant or friendly interactions, mentioned in 12.7% of reviews. Clean cars and an easy return process each appeared in 11.2%. At Hertz Car Rental, friendly staff led at 8.1%, followed by positive overall experiences at 7.1% and strongly positive service evaluations at 6.6%.
Staff or service interactions feature among the leading positive patterns for several companies, but the particular emphases vary. Enterprise’s top three also include vehicle cleanliness and returns, while ACE and Drivo feature favorable vehicle assessments. These are descriptive themes, not grounds for ranking companies. Whole-review tone, individual claims, and complaints each capture a different layer of customer perception.
Top negative patterns by company
Each company’s three leading negative patterns are ranked by claim count. The percentages describe the share of reviews containing each pattern, so the ranking and review shares may differ.
ACE Rent A Car’s listed concerns include delayed refunds and dissatisfaction with the car, each reported in 4.2% of reviews, and a stated reluctance to rent again, reported in 5.2%. The themes cover a post-rental concern and wider assessments, without showing that one caused another.
For Budget Car Rental, poor vehicle condition appeared in 7.7% of reviews. Prolonged waits appeared in 9.2%, and long lines in 8.7%. The leading patterns therefore include concerns about both pickup and the vehicle.
Drivo Rent A Car’s leading patterns include strongly negative assessments: each of two such descriptions appeared in 10.2% of reviews. Warnings to be cautious appeared in 8.6%. Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s leading patterns combine negative or disappointing overall assessments, found in 6.6% and 6.1% of reviews, with reports of poor staff treatment, found in 3.0%.
Avis Car Rental’s top three patterns are broad negative assessments, each appearing in 4.0% to 5.1% of reviews. Hertz Car Rental’s listed patterns include general negative judgments and poor customer service, with each reported in 10.2% to 11.7% of reviews.
The summaries range from specific operational concerns to broad dissatisfaction. They describe aspects of customer perception in these datasets, not the causes of reported experiences or a ranking of company quality.
What the combined findings reveal
Whole-review sentiment, claim-level sentiment, and topics in negative reviews measure different parts of the feedback. No one measure captures the full experience described in these reviews.
The overall tone differed sharply between Avis Car Rental and Hertz Car Rental. Positive reviews made up 85.4% of Avis’s reviews and 24.4% of Hertz’s. Negative reviews accounted for 12.1% of Avis’s and 75.1% of Hertz’s. Claim-level shares show another contrast: 57.5% of Hertz’s classified claims were negative and 15.9% positive, while Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s were 20.3% negative and 57.5% positive. A review may contain multiple claims, so claim-level shares describe the mix of classified statements, not the proportion of reviews with each sentiment.
Problem resolution and trust or transparency appeared more often in negative reviews from the ACE and Drivo datasets than in several other cohorts. Problem resolution appeared in 39.0% of ACE’s negative reviews and 23.9% of Drivo’s. Trust or transparency appeared in 34.1% and 25.4%, respectively. Speed or efficiency appeared in 44.9% of Budget’s negative reviews, compared with 23.6% of Hertz’s. A negative review can describe more than one issue, so topic shares need not add up to 100%.
Positive patterns add detail. Praise for staff or customer service appears among leading patterns in several cohorts, while Enterprise’s leading themes also include clean cars and an easy return process. These patterns describe different parts of the reported experience. They do not explain why experiences differed or establish a service-quality ranking. Overall tone and the praise or complaints within reviews are related, but they are not interchangeable.
ACE Rent A Car: positive and negative experiences
In the ACE Rent A Car dataset, 17.7% of reviews express a positive view of the service, and 14.1% regard the rental car positively. Positive comments about customer service associated with Shaun appeared in 9.4% of reviews. The pattern does not establish Shaun’s role.
The positive patterns cover service, the car, and a particular customer-service interaction. They describe distinct parts of satisfaction rather than a single measure.
Delayed refunds and dissatisfaction with the car each appeared in 4.2% of reviews in the ACE dataset. Reviewers saying they would not rent from the company again appeared in 5.2% of reviews. These themes capture different forms of dissatisfaction: a delayed refund, discontent with a vehicle, and an intention not to return.
Favorable comments about service and the car appear in the same dataset as complaints about refunds and vehicle experience. These patterns describe the accounts in this cohort. They do not explain why the experiences occurred or rank service quality.
Avis Car Rental: positive and negative experiences
In the Avis Car Rental dataset, positive patterns focus on customer service, gratitude, and strongly favorable evaluations. Customer-service praise appeared in 12.1% of reviews. Gratitude and highly positive service evaluations each appeared in 11.1%.
The leading negative patterns describe the experience broadly rather than identifying one specific complaint. Negative descriptions of Avis experiences appeared in 5.1% of reviews. Very poor assessments of the Avis rental-location experience appeared in 4.5%, and strongly negative assessments in 4.0%.
The positive patterns identify what reviewers valued, especially customer service. The leading negative patterns record overall dissatisfaction without specifying its cause. These are descriptive patterns in the Avis dataset, not explanations of why experiences differed or a ranking of service quality.
Budget Car Rental: positive and negative experiences
Budget Car Rental’s leading positive patterns, ranked by claim count, are highly positive evaluations of service, satisfaction with service, and positive descriptions of Antoinette. Highly positive service opinions appeared in 12.8% of reviews in the dataset. Satisfaction with service appeared in 10.8%, and positive descriptions of Antoinette in 4.1%. The pattern label does not identify Antoinette’s role.
Poor vehicle condition ranks first among the negative patterns by claim count, followed by prolonged waits and long lines. The review shares put the wait-related patterns ahead: 9.2% of reviews describe prolonged waits, 8.7% mention long lines, and 7.7% describe a car in poor condition. Pattern rank follows claim counts, while these percentages show how many reviews contain each pattern.
The positive summaries include service praise, while the negative summaries include complaints about queues and vehicle condition. These summaries do not show whether the same reviewers described both kinds of experience or explain why the experiences occurred. Overall review tone, claim-level patterns, and specific complaint topics describe different aspects of the feedback, not a verdict on service quality.
Drivo Rent A Car: positive and negative experiences
In the Drivo Rent A Car dataset, positive evaluations of the car appeared in 11.2% of reviews. An easy process and positive customer-service assessments each appeared in 10.2%. These descriptions refer to the vehicle, the process, and the service experience.
Very negative experience descriptions and strongly negative opinions of the company each appeared in 10.2% of reviews in this dataset. Warnings to be cautious appeared in 8.6%. These patterns convey the force of dissatisfaction but do not explain its cause.
At the whole-review level, 64.5% of reviews in the Drivo dataset were positive, 34.0% negative, and 1.5% neutral. Those overall ratings coexist in the dataset with specific positive and negative descriptions. The positive patterns do not erase the negative ones.
An overall review label and the particular experience described answer different questions. These are descriptive patterns in the analyzed Drivo feedback, not an explanation of why experiences differed or a ranking against other companies.
Enterprise Rent-A-Car: positive and negative experiences
Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s leading positive pattern concerns interactions: 12.7% of reviews in this dataset describe people at the Enterprise rental location as pleasant or friendly. Clean vehicles and an easy return process each appear in 11.2% of reviews. The themes cover personal contact and practical parts of the rental experience.
The leading negative patterns are broad assessments rather than reports about one specific service step. A negative assessment of the situation appeared in 6.6% of reviews, and an overall disappointing experience in 6.1%. Poor treatment by staff appeared in 3.0% of reviews, adding a specific interpersonal concern.
The leading positive patterns include pleasant interactions, while reports of poor treatment also appear among the leading negative patterns. The dataset contains distinct accounts of staff interactions alongside praise for cleanliness and return ease and broader expressions of disappointment.
These selected patterns do not inventory every theme or explain why experiences differed. Whole-review tone, claims within reviews, and complaint themes describe different layers of customer perception. These patterns describe Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s analyzed dataset, not a service-quality ranking.
Hertz Car Rental: positive and negative experiences
In the Hertz Car Rental dataset, friendly or nice staff were described in 8.1% of reviews. Positive overall experiences appeared in 7.1%, and strongly positive service evaluations in 6.6%.
These patterns include both descriptions of staff and broad assessments of the rental experience. Positive descriptions of the car also appear in the dataset, though they are outside its three leading patterns. The positive feedback therefore includes particular interactions as well as wider evaluations.
Negative assessments of Hertz appeared in 11.7% of reviews. Poor customer service and negative experiences each appeared in 10.2%. Among the more specific mapped patterns, reports that no cars were available at the Hertz rental location also appeared in 10.2% of reviews.
Friendly staff appears among the leading positive patterns, while poor customer service is a leading negative pattern. These are distinct reported experiences. They do not explain why they occurred or represent every rental. Staff interactions recur in positive patterns, while negative experiences take several forms. These summaries describe the Hertz dataset, not a ranking of providers.
What the findings add up to
Across the six Newark Liberty International Airport datasets, overall review sentiment, sentiment within individual claims, and topics in negative reviews describe related but distinct parts of the feedback. Each measures a different unit of response.
Avis Car Rental had the highest positive share among the analyzed datasets, at 85.4%. Hertz Car Rental had the lowest, at 24.4%. Negative reviews accounted for 12.1% of Avis’s reviews and 75.1% of Hertz’s. Claim-level sentiment also differed: negative claims made up 57.5% of Hertz’s classified claims and 20.3% of Enterprise Rent-A-Car’s, while positive claims accounted for 15.9% and 57.5%, respectively. A review can contain both praise and criticism, so claim-level shares need not match the sentiment assigned to whole reviews.
Problem-resolution concerns appeared in 39.0% of ACE Rent A Car’s negative reviews and 23.9% of Drivo Rent A Car’s, compared with 11.5% to 20.8% in the other four datasets. Transparency concerns appeared more often in negative reviews from ACE and Drivo, at 34.1% and 25.4%, than in the other datasets, where shares ranged from 4.2% to 7.7%. A negative review can describe more than one issue, so these topic shares are not additive.
Efficiency appeared in 44.9% of Budget Car Rental’s negative reviews, compared with 23.6% of Hertz Car Rental’s. Praise for staff or customer service recurs among the leading positive patterns for ACE, Avis, Drivo, Enterprise, and Hertz, though the descriptions vary. Enterprise’s leading positive patterns also include clean cars and an easy return process, each mentioned in 11.2% of reviews.
These findings describe the analyzed datasets, not the causes of experiences or every renter’s experience. This study does not rank companies or their branches. It helps companies identify reported product and service quality gaps that they can use to guide improvements.
Figures come from the analyzed public-review datasets. Overall review sentiment and sentiment within individual claims use separate denominators.
Blamery can run sentiment analysis and identify positive and negative patterns in public online feedback about your company or product, as well as competing companies or products. Explore the free demo, or contact us for custom marketing research.
